Monday, December 29, 2014

Gear of the Year Ballots, Part II

Continuing our trip through the various parts of the gear world, we land on some very thoughtful and interesting opinions. 

Here we go with round 2 (the final round, my ballot, comes out Friday):

Chris Weinstein's Ballot:

Overall Product of the Year:

Jarosz Knives Globetrotter Fixed Blades for around $100 - $120 with a leather sheath, you get an hand made custom knife with high performance AEB-L Blade steel. The coolest part about these is that every couple weeks, Jesse, does what he calls Sale Sunday where be blows out a dozen or so of a certain model. More often than not it's fixed blades. I had a chance to check out the Globetrotter I had for a giveaway. I'm not really a fixed blade guy but this things is just too much value to dismiss. The ergos are great and Jesse is notorious for making ridiculously scary sharp knives. For $100 the value is hard to dismiss. The reason I'd call the Globetrotter. "Product of the year" is it's within the reach of most budgets. If you are kind of on the fence and haven't decided if you are ready drop the money on a quality knife, $100 is a great way to test the waters. As far as an ambassador of quality knives, the Globetrotter is a great option. And if you have already made the jump to quality, take $300 and grab a few. One for the vehicle, one for the bug out bag and one to carry.

Company of the Year:

I'm giving this one to BladeHQ.  In 2014 Blade HQ has continued to be all things to all knife knuts. Yes it's true that BHQ is just a knife dealer but they do it so well and they make buying knives such an enjoyable experience that I feel they strengthen the knife community as a whole. They are not always the cheapest and they don't always have EVERYTHING in stock. But the Blade HQ brand has seemed to do more the hobby than anything that has come before them, be it product, website, gadget, or resource.

Best Value:

The District 9 flipper model from Reate Knives. I was able to borrow one for a few weeks from a friend. Yes I know we are supposed to be sick of ti frame lock flippers, and I am, trust me! But this knife was impressive, especially with the stigma that comes with a knife being "Made in china". From my experience the the knives coming out of Reate knives are made with high end materials, amazing fit and finish, function flawlessly and they are an incredible value.

Most Innovative Tool:

I'm going to give this to the the KEY-BAR. The inventor Mike Taylor is a good friend of mine and I'll admit that in the beginning I wasn't 100% sold on the KEY-BAR but I supported him and helped promote the concept to people who may find it useful. I only carry a few keys so I personally didn't see much use for it.

While titanium is relatively light weight, adding two slabs of it to my limited set of keys just felt counter productive and not very practical. Keep in mind, I had a generation 1 KEY-BAR, I installed my keys, tried to get use to it and I saw some of the benefits, but in the end I decided it wasn't for me.

Fast forward to 2014, I found myself up near KEY-BAR HQ in Savannah GA and had a chance to sit down with Mike for a podcast interview. I came home from that trip with a couple of KEY-BARs that Mike offered up as Knife Thursday giveaways. Long story short, I kept one, my wife saw me using it and said, "I want one" and I gave the other away to a friend.

Once I spent some time with the KEY-BAR as part of my every day setup it became more and more obvious that I would never go back. The KEY-BAR as a product has integrated itself so seamlessly into our every day lives that my wife calls her keys her "KEY-BAR". We have our keys set up exactly the same way, home, office, inlaws and shop keys all in the same place on each others KEY-BARS. We also, each have a small lock back SOG key knife that fits great with the system. Seeings how far the KEY-Bar has come over the past year I'd say the KEY-BAR is not only tool of the year for 2014, but one to watch for 2015.

Best Production Knife:

I polled some of the KT Ambassadors on this and they all are saying the Sebenza 21 & 25 are the undisputed king of the mountain unless it has to be a new product then they all say the Spyderco Chubby.

Personally I'll go with 4 choices based on what seemed to be the most popular in the community.

First, the Boker Kwaiken flipper designed by Lucas Burnley seemed to be a huge hit with modifiers.

Second, the newest generation of the DPx Gear Triple Black HEST [EDITOR'S NOTE: Lisa Pelton of DPx told Chris, in a follow up email, that there were a tiny handful of Triple Black's released last year...but whatever]. I like the fact that it's relatively sterile with very few logos on it compared to the standard HEST Oh wait was the current gen triple black HEST not a new model for 2014? Well... I equally like the HEAT from DPx Gear. Specifically the full ti version. It's actually a better knife but the blade is s tad bit too short for some EDC tasks. Either way I really like it.

Third, the QTRMSTR Spicoli QSE7 seems to be blowing people away. It has a lot of features that you would expect from a knife at a higher price point. There is no denying the appealing design and from what I hear the thing carries, cuts and flips like a dream.

Finally, the District 9 flipper model from Reate Knives. See more on this above.

With all that being said... Production knife of the year goes to the Chris Reeve Sebenza 21, any configuration, all day, any day, any year for the foreseeable future. The knife is so good as a folder that I think if a worthy contender arrives, it will be undeniable the second it comes on the scene. It has to be THAT good. For a knife to dethrone the Sebenza 21 it will need to literally make the Sebenza look like out-dated technology.

Best Custom Knife:

Demko Knives AD10. (Andrew Demko 2010)  In a sea of titanium frame lock flippers on both the custom and production sides of the aisle, it's nice to see someone doing something different and totally crushing it. Andrew Demko is a full time designer at Cold Steel and the originator of the Tri-Ad lock that is featured on his AD10 customs and most of the Cold Steel lineup.

He also has a wait a mile long with the secondary market on his folders double sometimes triple the table price. Recently Andrew listed a one off AD10 for sale on his instagram @DemkoKnives at table price and it was sold in seconds. The other reason i'm going with the AD10 here is that over the past year I've had the honor of spending some time with a very nice selection of folders from Andrew. Five AD10s to be exact.

I ended up adding one of them to my collection permanently. It's one of those knives that when carried, you just feel like the universe is aligned in your favor. This knife is such an incredible example of what a high end custom hard use folder can be, and you own it? It really does get any better. I just find myself thinking. What did I do to deserve this?

It used to be that Andrew was known as "The Cold Steel Guy" but more and more these days he has become known for the AD10. 5 seconds with an AD10 will silence any doubt you have. I've seen it happen, "Oh it's a lock baaaa... oh shit this thing is FUCKING BAD" That's normally how it goes.

Best Production Light:

The $15 Streamlight single AAA that I have bought 5 of this year. Kids keep loosing them. Plenty flashlight for my needs and cheap enough that I dont loose my shit when they turn up missing.

Best Custom Light:

Huh?

Best Pack:

I have one.

Best Pen:

Fisher space pen. Enough with the pens already.

Best Multitool:

I need to upgrade. I'm rocking a Leatherman Sidekick that debuted in 2012. I'm sure there are far better offerings available now tough, the Side kick does pretty well and has help up well.

Best Accessory:

Custom turned lanyard beads from @Scoopyloops on ig and @EdgeObserver. I'm not really a lanyard guy, but i've made an exception for a few knives. Once of which is my Carbon Fiber Knife Art Insingo Large 21 Sebenza which is currently sporting one of the classiest titanium lanyard beads I've ever seen. The bead that came on the knife was already classy, but the Edge Observer bead from Andrew takes it to a whole new level.

The Scoopyloops beads are massive. One of the cool things about Jon Brown's beads is that he makes them out of various materials including ti, brass and copper. Nothing beats small folder that has been "scoopylooped". The massive beads add a level of welcome utility to an otherwise small folder. For instance, my Microtech mini UDT didn't really have a place in my rotation until it was scoopylooped. Just a tad bit too small, the lanyard / massive bead combo rectified that.

Best EDC-related Crowd Funded Project:

Again, I'll say the KEY-BAR. While not crowd funded in the traditional sense of running a Kickstarter, the story of the rise of KEY-BAR is what American dreams are made of. Mike saw so much success with the popularity of the KEY-BAR in the Knife/EDC community that his life literally changed over night. This was largely due to the support of the community. Maybe the difference from the KEY-BAR and other crowd funded products, is that the KEY-BAR orders were filled as they came in and not in the way of perks down the road once a goal.

Best Website/YouTube/Podcast/Instagram

Website:

EdgeObserver.com I credit E/O for getting me into knives and opening my eyes to knives as more than just cutting tools. If it wasn't for E/O I may not appreciate knives and the topic of knives an an art form and base for content creation.

Youtube:

Terafanatic featuring the Wieners & Steel.  What Knife Knut doesn’t want to visit Clifton New Jersey and grab a Ripper while checking out $10,000 worth of custom knives with four of his or her closest friends?  Friendship & Knives with a side of Hotdogs, hold the bullshit. The Wieners and Steel crew is made up of  four of the coolest people in the knife community and possibly the world.  @froochie @fastbandit @menovade and @terafanatic have been cranking out knife hangout videos since June 6th 2013 when they published their very first episode on on Terafanatic’s youtube channel.  Terafanatic has been dubbed the “Head Wiener In Charge” or HWIC by the rest of the crew though he takes no credit for the success of the project. In fact, the guys are surprisingly casual about the show considering it’s popularity.  As far as the they are concerned it’s just hanging out with the boys. And THAT is why they are loved by so many of us.  I love these guys so much that I based our very first Knife Shirt on them. You can check it out Knife Shirt Club (shameless). And I also like Utility Talk. Like Gear Geeks :ive, Utility Talk are touching on a lot of different topics than knives. As you can imagine, I can easily get burnt out on knife chat.

Podcast:

Besides the obvious answers, I'll say that I do enjoy the Knife Journal even though those guys are into a total difference area of the knife community than I am.

Instagram:

I'm going to give this to @Derk_Razor_Sharp. He is a cool dude, he has a little girl, a hot wife, a sick knife collection and a epic beard. Plus he is Canadian so you know he's guaranteed to be super nice. But in all honesty, Derek and I have very similar taste in knives so I always find myself checking in on his IG to see what he's up to. My second and obvious choice would be @FastBandit

Community Leader:

I'll give this one to the Wieners & Steel guys along with the rest of the Knife Thursday Ambassadors. I chose the KT Ambassadors based on a few criteria, one of which was that they were good leaders in their own sphere of influence. They each have their own micro communities and best of all they are all really good friends of mine. Another criteria is that they must have made a few post or contributions to knifethursday.com in the past. This explains why Anthony is not on that list. Maybe we can rectify that in 2015.

Grayson Parker's Ballot:

Overall Product of the Year:

It's tough for me to say. Titanium framelocks are incredibly stale. I'm going to refrain from nominating anything, but I hope to see something other than $100+ Ti/Flipper/Framelocks. It's old.

Company of the Year:

Emerson Knives. This might sound weird, but what they're doing is honestly way more interesting than KAI. That collaboration was a two-way street, and if we're looking at this as a networking thing, the fact that EKI is improving their F&F issues (consumer complaint), offering more designs in the standard EKI line up (that consumers have pushed for: Hattin, Mini CQC7AW), moved into other markets with the KAI collab (see again, consumer pressure), moved into the multitool market with the Multitasker collabs, and still kept up a good name? That's not something I see a lot of companies doing. I don't think KAI did something new; to them, it's just another collaboration. But for EKI, it was a huge move.

Best Value:

Spyderco Native 5 Lightweight. Great ergonomics, blade shape, materials, and it's made in Golden. I haven't handled this one but I think it's a sleeper hit for the year. The Kershaw/ZT/EKI collabs I handled were underwhelming.

Most Innovative Tool:

DPx HIT Cutter. Solves the sheath problem, though I think I'll like the Skinner more. Haven't handled this one, so consider it a tentative nomination.

Best Production Knife:

Having handled the ZT0454 for awhile, yeah, it's the cutting edge of knives. However, there is no social situation outside of enthusiasts chatting where using that thing is appropriate. It has my nomination, but Manny and Mario are right, it's a prison shank.

Best Production Light:

Zebralight H52w, [EDITOR'S NOTE: Grayson did some post-submission checking and discovered that the H52w was released in December of 2013...close enough for me). While it didn't have the market impact that the SC52 did, the H52 fulfilled a request that a lot of customers were putting forward: the performance of the SC52 in an angled body. I've used it for night reading when no other light was available, looking for black widows when I'm in the garage at night, and most utility tasks. As a pocket light (sans clip) it's great, as a headlamp, it's great, and because of that it's my choice. There's not a whole lot of gear that operates in both the EDC and lightweight backpacking worlds, but this definitely does.

Best Pen:

I'd say the Tactile Turn Shaker in Titanium, but I backed the Kickstarter because of Tony and Brad's opinions, and mine hasn't been shipped yet. Sticking with my Kaweco Sport Al until then (not that I can nominate it). [EDITOR'S NOTE: Grayson got it and loves it.]

Best Multitool:

The multitool market is dry as shit right now. I don't care if Victorinox rebrands Wenger stuff or if someone finds another tool configuration to fit into the SAK/Leatherman shape. I'm going to say the Spyderco Clipitool, even though the ones I handled were a bit stiff. They're smart designs, really accessible, and well built. On top of that, they represent some fresh blood in the multitool market, which is really why I'm excited about it.

Dan Policastro's Ballot:

Overall Product of the Year: ZT 0454
Company of the Year: Zero Tolerance
Best Value: Kershaw Emerson Collaboration or Buck Marksman
Most Innovative Tool: SOG Blade Light (just kidding... no idea really)

Best Production Knife: ZT 0454
Best Custom Knife: Dustin Turpin Strife (or anything else he made this year)

Best Production Light: Not sure - haven't been following the market so closely
Best Custom Light: Not sure again

Best Pack: (No idea)
Best Pen: (No idea)
Best Multitool: Spyderco Clip It (thin pickings here)
Best Accessory:

Best EDC-related Crowd Funded Project: Obtanium Wallet
Best Website/YouTube/Podcast/Instagram: Average Iowa Guy
Community Leader: Tony Sculimbrene

Justin Laffer's Ballot:

Overall Product of the Year:

Strider Performance Series SnG – the evolution of the gold standard of the custom knife world – Mick has essentially made a custom Strider for 550 dollars – the fit and finish are better than any other Midtech in the knife industry bar none

Company of the Year:

Chad Nichols Damascus – they made the Southard, Burch and Graham Midtech – they single handedly made this the year of the Midtech, they more than ANY other company had the greatest effect on the EDC community

Best Value:

The Graham Stubby Midtech -350 dollars for a rock solid, razor sharp folder that one of the top maker in the game – totally amazing work

Most Innovative Tool:

The GTC Airborne – by far the most innovative and awe-inspiring knife/tool available – if you just want pocket tools than I’d have to go with the Rexford RUT

Best Production Knife:

The Sebenza 25 – truly amazing or the CRKT Hi Jinx – but I differ judgement on this as I’m not really a production guy

Best Custom Knife:

GTC Airborne – without a doubt the most incredible and innovative custom knife on the market. Runner up – the Munroe Sigil MK3 – the most perfect EDC folder ever created – totally amazing

Best Production Light:

Prometheus Lights Beta QR Copper light – so freaking awesome-

Best Custom Light:

Don’t know if Prometheus is considered production or custom. EDITOR'S NOTE: Jason, that's a good sign.

Best Pack:

GoRuck GR1

Best Pen:

Prometheus Writes Ti Pen with mont blanc refill

Best Multitool:

Rexford RUT

Best Accessory:

Joseph 76 MOA beads…I love the fact that Joseph makes these beads in so many configurations – my favorite is the Westinghouse micarta bead or the copper bead

Best EDC-related Crowd Funded Project:

The Hate Project – this EDC group by some of the finest people in the community have raised 151,000 dollars for charities this year.  That is unreal.

Best Instagram:

Dustin Turpin – his WIP threads are legendary as is his support for the community

Best YouTube:

Probably Edge Observer or Stick to Drums – both make excellently produced videos that thankfully are not 20 minutes long and filled with ramblings about prices

Community Leader:

Farmer Rob the founder the of the Hate Project.

Friday, December 26, 2014

Gear of the Year Ballots, Part I

The adherence to the two rules and the seriousness of each ballot varies, but that creates some delightful humor and inconsistency.

Here we go:

Ben Schwartz's Ballot:

Overall Product of the Year:

I'll talk about it more down below, but I would nominate the modded production knife as the Product of the Year. Modding has been around for years now, I know, but this is the year that I saw the most, and the coolest, work done in that field. Custom knives are wonderful, but hard to get and expensive. To have a production knife you really dig turned into something unique that only YOU own is such a cool idea, and usually more affordable with less of a turn-around time, than getting a custom.

Company of the Year:

Kai. They've been really good for years now, but in 2014 they really crushed it, giving entry-level enthusiasts something to love with the Emerson collabs, catering to fans of the cutting edge and high-end with their bevy of cool new ZTs AND their limited release stuff, AND showing, once again, that they understand and listen to their customer base with the release of the G-10 Cryo. I've also heard nothing but good things about their customer service (I'll have some personal experience with that soon, as I recently broke the Speedsafe on my Cryo...) I think other companies have made individual products that are more striking, or that appeal to me specifically more, but for all-around market mastery and sheer proliferation of quality, I think that Kai just owned this year.

Best Value:

Kershaw/Emerson collabs. In my opinion it really redefined what an entry-level user can get for $30. Excellent work. On the other end of the value spectrum I'd nominate the Three Sisters Forge Beast. $300 for a custom knife of this level of quality is just insane. For something in the middle I'd pick Kizer Cutlery's stuff, for obvious reasons.

Best Production Knife:

Tough one. Maybe the Northwoods Knives Indian River Jack? It's been around before, of course, but the value proposition is hard to ignore, and the performance and people-friendly looks probably seal the deal. At the risk of sounding redundant I'm going to say as well the Kershaw/Emerson stuff is worth another mention. Benchmade's 940-1 is also super badass, and really needs to be seen in person to be appreciated; it totally bowled me over.

Best Custom Knife:

The huge caveat here is that I have little experience with customs; I only handled two this year: Tony's Fellhoelter Compact Dauntless and my own TSF Beast. That being said, I'm going to say the Beast has my vote: stunning quality and utility at a price that you just can't argue with. Broken record, I know...also relatedly, as I said above, I'd call 2014 the year of the custom-modded production knife: so many guys are out there making production knives that are easy to find unique and awesome with their work, and they probably deserve a mention as well.

Best Production Light:

Thrunite T10T.

Best Pen:

Tactile Turn Mover or Shaker.  Personally I like my Prometheus Alpha Pen better, but in all fairness I've had mine since last year, so this deserves the prize.

Best Youtube:

This year I really got into Average Iowa Guy's videos. I find the conversational pace and tone refreshingly different from so much of the gear review/discussion videos out there.

Andrew Gene's Ballot

Overall Product of the Year:

Bear Grylls Ultimate Pro Survival Knife.  I’ve finally found something to replace my hollow handled United Cutlery Rambo knife although sadly, this one doesn’t have a fishing kit in the handle.  The orange makes me feel clean even if I’ve been eating grubs and drinking my own piss in the jungle for weeks.  Staring into it on a rainy day reminds me of better times.  Not to mention the Ultimate Guide to Survival guide can help you find a Denny’s after a hard trek in enemy territory.  Outside of this I’d probably pick the ZT 0454 (sorry, no link; there is no product page) is it counts seeing as it really came out last year.

Company of the Year:

Shirogorov or CKF.  Awesome designs.  Current but distinct.  CKF has especially been putting out some interesting knives.  KAI would be a second pick as a very mature company who continues to innovate despite their established success in the industry.

Best Value:

Kershaw Nura 3 and 3.5.  If I were an Emerson fan I’d say the Kemershaws but I’m not.  A cheap KVT Sinkevich does seem like a pretty awesome deal.

Most Innovative Tool:

Maker Bot or 3D Systems Cube 3D printers.  3D printers are changing the way everything is tested and manufactured and will have a lasting impact on the gear industry as a whole.

Best Production Knife:

A couple of picks here. The Rockstead SAI.    LionSteel Ti Dust.  Well the Ti Dust is technically a prototype but it ties in nicely with the 3D printing bit.  For knives you can buy I’m not sure.  The 0454 was my favorite release but again, I don’t know if you can consider it of 2014.  Same with the 0888MAX.  The CRKT Hi Jinx would be up there too.  It was a super ambitious knife for CRKT. 

Best Custom Knife:

Hard to pick but one of Enrique Pena’s traditional folders with modern materials would get my vote.  I don’t think a flipper should win this category simply because there are so many.  Don’t get me wrong, I love a flipper but I like how these knives beat to their own drum.    I believe Marcin Slysz also put out some of these.  For more “fashionable” work I like the designs from Dmitry Sinkevich but I’ve never handled any of his customs so I can’t comment on the fit and finish although I’m sure it’s excellent....

Best Production Light:

No Idea, haven’t bought a light for years.  I do love the Jil Lite Constel though.  So practical as a general light source.  It comes with me everywhere these days.

Best Custom Light:

No idea, I’ve never owned or handled a custom flashlight.

Best Pack:

Lowe Pro Runner Pro 450.  I use this bag like crazy.  Lo Pro bags are pretty ugly but do an excellent job of holding camera equipment, or anything else you want to carry around.  They have been making affordable bags for people who rely on them professionally for some time.  No frills, decent ergos and last forever. 

Best Pen:

My old Meister Stuck Solitaire because I use it everyday and it was my father’s pen.  I don’t have any practical experience with any other pens.

Best Multitool:

I haven’t handled anything new in ages.  Again I’ll have to go with the one I use, the Leatherman Squirt PS4.

Best Accessory:

Vox Snail.  Soon you won’t have to buy one, they’ll be coming to your door trying to take over your house.  THEY’RE EVERYWHERE

Best EDC-related Crowd Funded Project:

No Idea but if was a movie I’d say Kung Fury.

Best Website/YouTube/Podcast/Instagram:

@knives for IG and Knife Thursday online.

Community Leader:

Chris Weinstein.  He really does the most outreach and KT is based on community participation.

Mario Contino's Ballot:

Overall Product of the Year:

Keurig 2.0. It is love. It is life.

Company of the Year:

Kai USA. Spyderco puts holes in their knives and Benchmade is boring.

Best Value:

Victorinox Alox Pioneer - This will be the norm forever.

Most Innovative Tool:

Overtone Labs' Tune-Bot drum tuner. I was pretty good before, but damn my drums sing now.

Best Production Knife:

Kershaw Carbon Fiber Skyline--hands down the coolest EDC-oriented knife that takes a budget platform and polishes it off with a fatty rabbit hole.

Best Custom Knife:

Bob Lessard's custom Swiss Army Knives. With a choice of tools in the alox 93mm platform, you can't beat this for custom made practicality.

Best Production Light:

Foursevens' Preon P2 High CRI Edition head. The body is lame though, it's best on a Preon P1 body.

Best Custom Light:

MBI Torpedo...the experimental build. Technically not a light yet, but mine is pretty great.

Best Pack:

12-pack of 16oz cans of Surge. Relive the soda of the 90s.

Best Pen:

Parker Jotter. Better than every other million-dollar pen.

Best Multitool:

Again, Bob Lessard's custom Swiss Army Knives.

Best Accessory:

Kershaw cadet cap.

Best EDC-related Crowd Funded Project:

No idea...

Best Website/YouTube/Podcast/Instagram/Community Leader:

CutleryBlubber, Gagkoo, fancyfeast, terracottamechanic, etc. Ya know, the usual.  

Mike Rixman's Ballot

Overall Product of the Year: 

This one's had me stumped. I think this should be more than just a flashy product; one that affects the entire industry with continued ripples after the big splash. With that in mind, I'm tempted to play Devil's advocate and say that the product of the year is Balzano's "knife" (Part I and Part II)(can't even find the name, since so many people are backpedaling and erasing posts to distance themselves).

Focus on the positive ripples rather than the initial impact of the turd. Many mistakes were made - both on his end as well as his customers who were naive, rushing blindly to be part of "the next big thing," and were too accepting of his excuses. I think that the lessons learned from these missteps have already positively affect how makers, modders, and customers interact. With any luck this situation will serve as a lesson that prevents a repeat.

Company of the Year:

Zero Tolerance - the 0801CF, 0562CF, 0620CF, and the 0454 - A string of hits, and it seems like they are printing money at this point.

Best Value:

Kershaw/Emerson CQC-6K. It is designed and built way beyond its price tag. I'd vote for the 6K over the 7K since the 8Cr14MoV won't hold an edge especially well, and this blade shape will facilitate sharpening.  I'd also nominate Spyderco Manix2 LW in CPM S110V

Most Innovative Tool:

My vote would be for the Leatherman Leap--they opened up a whole new market with a tool that maintains many of the best characteristics from other models, yet is tailored to the specific needs of children.  I'd also nominate the Lionsteel TiDust and the Klecker Knives Klax

Best Production Knife:

Spyderco Manix2 LW in CPM S110V - The design isn't new, but bringing such a premium steel to the masses in a non-sprint run, and at just over $ 100 is quite an accomplishment. Benchmade 940-1

Best Custom Knife:

Jens Anso's Mojo Extreme (check his IG) just absolutely blew my mind and now I can't think of anything else.

Best Production Light:

Version 2 of the Prometheus Lights Beta QR in copper. Same fantastic light but with a smaller and easier Quick Release mechanism. Last year's 2-mode has been in my pocket (without the quick release) uninterrupted for several months.

Best Custom Light:

Muyshondt Aeon II. Not exactly new, but this is the last batch that he will be making (again), so possibly the last chance acknowledge it.

Best Pack:

No data. Anything but the Eddie Bower POS that my wife bought me.

Best Pen:

Tactile Turn Mover. Wide array of refills and supreme fit and finish: it's the only pen that motivated me to buy a non-disposable pen.

Best Multitool:

Leatherman Leap if not selected for "Most Innovative Tool," and By The Numbers 4 if it was.

Best Accessory:

Nano-Oil
Aegis Solutions EDCi

Best EDC-related Crowd Funded Project:

Knife Thursday Podcast's Coffee Sponsorship

Best Website:

I'd nominate Blade HQ which has realtime inventory and full specs - usually the first place I go to lookup a knife.  Triple Aught Design earns a nomination for having a fair and reliable mechanism for distribution of limited quantities of a product - all the more significant given Kershaw's recent difficulties.

YouTube:

Edge Observer

Podcast:

I'd vote for Gear Geeks Live - really stepped up their game this year with improved sound quality and a string of great guests. Utility Talk. Knife Journal Podcast

Instagram:

@jimskeltontv - his photos are pretty spectacular and his feed keeps me amused.
@crossdraw_rob
@derk_razor_sharp
@tzvy

Community Leader:

Jim Skelton - the Diamond Jim's Live Knife Project attempted to bypass long wait times, closed books, and outrageous secondary market prices to put custom knives into peoples' hands.  Chris Weinstein - he does not merely engage and participate in the "knife and gear community," but actively tries to grow and cultivate it.

Monday, December 22, 2014

Gear of the Year Awards

Each year I like to do a wrap up on what was released and what was upgraded.  Here were the awards for 2012 and here they are for 2013.  In the past its been just me, writing in isolation.  I have tried to take points of view from around the community, but I have never actually reached out to folks.  This year I did something different.  I got a wide mix of folks to respond.  None were manufacturers, but I did that on purpose.  I want these awards to come from the community, not businesses.

A few rules: 1) only new stuff--emitter upgrades and new handle materials don't count (this is not a strict rule); and 2) things can only win once (this IS a strict rule).  Without the second rule the overall product of the year would dominate its specific category too.  The purpose is to highlight the good stuff out there and this second rule allows for more stuff to be included.

Here are the voters: 

The Gear Geeks Live crew:


Everyday Commentary Contributor:

Ben Schwartz

Knife Thursday Empresario:


Knowledgeable Folks in the Community:

Grayson Parker
Mike Rixman

Utility Talk Front Man:


The Funniest Guy on the USN:

Justin Laffer

Each was sent a ballot of categories and each filled out the ballot.  Here are the categories:

Overall Product of the Year
Company of the Year
Best Value
Most Innovative Tool

Best Production Knife
Best Custom Knife

Best Production Light
Best Custom Light

Best Pack
Best Pen
Best Multitool
Best Accessory

Best EDC-related Crowd Funded Project
Best Website/YouTube/Podcast/Instagram
Community Leader

I will publish a group of ballots on Friday, Tuesday, and then I will release my ballot on the following Friday.  

I think you will be impressed with the overall quality of responses, the depth of the answers, and just how varied folks are.  Feel free to chime in in the comments section.  The best ballot in the comments, as chosen by me, will win the Kizer Ki3404-3 I reviewed last month.  You can comment on any of the articles listing a ballot or on this article.    



Thursday, December 18, 2014

Zero Tolerance ZT0770CF Review

Out of the ashes...or so the saying goes. In this case it wasn't so much ashes as it was a flaming shipwreck.

KAI is never one to go lightly.  They either don't show up or they do and they bring the thunder.  Case in point--the Zero Tolerance ZT0777.  It was an insane, blank check blade, coming off the heels of another stellar design, the Tilt.  The ZT0777 had Vanax steel on the cutting edge, damascus on the spine, a contoured carbon fiber body, a subframe lock, a sculpted pocket clip, and a bearing pivot.  It was, frankly, a knife no one other than KAI could make.  No custom maker has the ability to do the composite blade and no other production company has the time to fidget with all of the crazy components.  And the reality is that version of the ZT0777 was a knife even KAI couldn't make.  After a few stops and starts, the sale of a handful of blades, they through in the towel.  It wasn't for lack of trying, but they just couldn't get the blade to work on any kind of scale.  They took a long time but in the end it wasn't meant to be.

But the design was beautiful and others took notice.  After the ZT0777 was announced but before it was released (or they gave up) another knife, the Microtech Matrix was announced and it bore more than a passing similarity to the ZT0777.  Here is a piece on the controversy.   In the end, the Matrix made it to mass market first and the ZT0777 had to be scrapped and reinvented as the ZT0777 M390, a knife with all the features of the original but for the composite blade.  As a spin off, KAI announced a smaller version of the knife, the ZT0770, which was also beaten to the market by the Microtech...wait for it...Mini Matrix.  The whole thing is a really sad commentary on the knife industry--a company's willingness to push the envelope is rewarded with a blatant ripoff.  Despite all of that hassle and bullshit, something good came of it--this knife.

Until the ZT0770 (hereinafter the 0770) most ZT's ranged from boat anchor to trade paperback in terms of their carry profile.  They are great knives, built like vaults, but man are they big.  The ZT560 was positively massive and the ZT350, their small knife, is giant too.  This says nothing for the Bunyanesque ZT0200 (7.8 ounces! Ahoy Matey!).  When Derrick sent me the 770 he prefaced it by saying it was one of his favorite knives.  The minute its slim profile slipped out of the box I knew why.  This is a ZT knife in EVERY SINGLE WAY--the materials, the fit and finish, and the design.  But it is also a knife that regular folks in regular jobs can carry and use.   

Here is the product page. The Zero Tolerance ZT0770CF costs $180.  There was an aluminum handled version, but that appears to have been discontinued.  Here is a written review. Here is a video review (he either got an uber rare version or he got the steel wrong--its Elmax not M390). Here is a link to KnivesShipFree, where you can find the ZT0770CF, and all proceeds benefit the site when you purchase things through this link:

KnivesShipFree

Here is my review sample (to be given away; I am trying a new set up for pictures, let me know what you think in the comments):

P1040918

Here is my video overview:



Twitter Review Summary: THE ZT for non-sasquatches--an awesome EDC blade.

Design: 2

The angles and cuts on this knife, the things that give it its shape, are so cool looking.  This is a knife that looks like a human muscle attached to the skeletal frame--taut, purposeful and poised.  I love the handle shape and lines of the knife.  Visual tension is here in spades.

P1040915

But this isn't just a pretty knife, its a well designed one too. 

Here is a size comparison:

P1040852

The performance ratios are very good: blade:weight is 1.08 (thank you Mr. Carbon Fiber) and the blade:handle is .76, the same as a SOG Flash I.  That last comparison is something I find stunning and testament to how great this knife is.  This is easily in the same class as the Benchmade 940-1 and the Spyderco Paramilitary 2--truly rarefied company in the production world. 

Fit and Finish: 2

At this point it is a cliche to talk about how wonderful the fit and finish is on a ZT knife.  Frankly I am at a loss as to how to do it other than to say that it is awesome.  Take a look at the decorative pivot screw borrowed from the ZT0777:

P1040861

It fits the knife nicely and provides a bit of silver bling to match the flawless carbon fiber.  The centering is superb and that is something given how thin this knife is and how thick the blade steel is--there is no room for error.  The  stonewashing is even and excellent.  Everything is just great.  I feel like a Motor Trend writer trying to find new ways to say that a Ferrari is fast.  You get the point though--ZT is making some of the finest production knives in the world and the 0770 is no different.

Grip: 1

In a nod to the EDC role of the 0770 the jimping, which can be positively skin shredding on some ZTs, is toned way down.  The excellent grip, instead, comes from a wonderful handle shape.

P1040860

As you can see the knife just nestles into my hand, with the flipper doing double duty as a finger guard.   Its a great shape.  One thing I would mention, not as a criticism so much, but as an explanation of a difference, is that the aluminum version, which was discontinued (probably because it was too much like the Mini Matrix) and the Microtech rip off, both had some sculpting to the handle and that did feel better.  The CF, especially on the clip side, is slick.  That's not to say the grip here is bad, its not, as the score tells you, but it could be better.

Carry: 2

I originally bought a ZT0200 as my first ZT.  Oh my god was that thing huge.  It felt like I was carry a hand grenade in my pocket (the scale's texture helped convey that sensation in addition to the knife's portly dimensions).  Fortunately I was able to exchange it for the diminutive (by comparison) ZT0350.  The effect was immediate--that knife seemed manageable. But when I got it home I was struck by how it felt compared to other knives.  It too was too big in the pocket.  In the end every ZT has had the curse until now.  The 0770 is just great in the pocket, truly superior. ZT now makes and EDC blade and the ZT0770 is it.

Steel: 2

This my fourth or fifth knife with Elmax and it never once let me down.  This is a great cutting steel and not hard to maintain.  In the holiday season my knives get a real workout.  I am still processing some firewood and I am also breaking down boxes like a fiend.  Our extra tiny recycling can has been, perhaps, the best thing that could happen to my knife testing regime.  The 0770's Elmax has been great.  Perhaps all of the Elmax haters out there haven't had enough experience with the blade, but as my number of reviews approaches 250 items, I feel confident in saying that Elmax is one of the better steels on the market.

Blade Shape: 2

Its too much to say this blade shape is innovative.  It bears more than passing resemblance to the modified sheepfoot on the Mini Grip 555hg. But it is not a stretch to say that it is different, and in this case

P1040855

the difference is very good.  I like the less aggro shape, perfect for EDC and I truly appreciate the loss of a recurve edge. The ZT350 was a beast to sharper, what with the hard S30V steel and the recurve.  Thankfully, none of that exists here and the the 0770 was both easy to strop and sharpen.

Grind: 2

The high grind is even and thin (VERY thin compared to other ZT knives).  It is also very well done.  The cutting bevel is wide allowing the knife to register well for use on sharpening stones and the like.  I appreciated the true ricasso here as well.  Not a single problem with the grind. 

Deployment Method: 1

You can de-assist this knife, but the action is mediocre.  I know that assisted openers sell well, but this is an enthusiast knife, priced at $180, so I don't know why they left it assisted.  Enthusiasts do not like assisted knives.  They just don't.  If they did, there would be more assisted customs (I can't even think of any off the top of my head).  This knife with a bearing pivot or good washers would be awesome.  The flipper is a great shape and size, I just dislike assisted opening knives.  In addition to that, the assist felt balky in some ways.  It wasn't slow, it just seemed to engage at different places along the opening path at different times and for no real reason.  If you like assists, ignore this complaint and go back to your collection of half-serrated knives you philistine.  I kid, I kid...not really. 

Retention Method: 2

Look familiar?

P1040863

Its the clip from the Cryo and it is one of my favorite production clips.  I don't need over the top but it is done so well here I don't mind.  It is also quite stable, long enough to lock the blade in place, and keep it from moving (though that probably has more to do with the size of the knife than the size of the clip).  Its not a paint scraper either.  Very good.  

Lock: 2

Man I agonized over this score.  The lock works.  Its strong and stable.  It engages easily.  But...eh...its hard to get at.  The scales, as you can see:

P1040849

Are cut up right around it, making it hard to wedge your finger in to disengage the lock.  The lock works perfectly, its just not brain dead easy to disengage.  If the scale were a little more refined, I would have given this something like a 1.5, but its not so I give it a 2 and note the shortcoming in the text.  If you have thin fingers, this will be a non-issue.  I don't have Polish sausage digits by any means and I still had a little trouble.  

Overall Score: 18 out of 20

There are three places I am not perfectly satisfied with the knife, but none are huge deals.  Each is a little niggling thing, like a mediocre side dish in an splendid seven course meal.  As a package, the ZT0770CF competes with the best the production world has to offer in terms of high end, larger EDC knives.  It is certainly in the same league as the PM2 and the 940-1.  Its also the cheapest of those three, other than the S30V PM2 (is it time to stop calling S30V a premium steel?  I think so...).  I liked the 0770 a lot and I can see why Derrick liked it.  If you don't have the coin for the 940-1 or you want a flipper, get the 0770.  Its heritage may have been godlike, but this blade ain't no slouch.  A demigod of larger EDC knives perhaps?

P1040857

Monday, December 15, 2014

Two Cool EDC-related Celebrity Videos.

Adam Savage from Mythbusters really knows what he is doing with his EDC.  Here he lays out all of his daily carry and though I wish he had a better light and I get the sentimental reasons for the Rolex, everything else seems pretty darn good.  


If you haven't taken a listen, the Still Untitled podcast is a pretty great show. Its not EDC-related but the topics are varied and the hosts are interesting.

The second video, found only in link form, is this video from the Travel Channel showing Jacques Pepin deboning a chicken.  I post it here because this is a master demonstrating some very precise knife techniques, all used to perfection.  There are "faster" guys out there (Martin Chan) but none a quick and precise.  When I say "knife skills" this is one of the more practical demonstrations of what I mean. 

Thursday, December 11, 2014

Chris Reeve Mnandi Review

Man has this review been tough.  Not because the knife is bad or complicated.  It is simple, subtle perfection.  The problem is what to do with the new model.  Cohost of the podcast, Dan from Blade Reviews, lent me his Mnandi for testing and it is an "old model". The new model, released in 2013 and produced since is a much worse knife ("worse" being relative, its still a great blade, just not as good as the old model).  So how do I review the Mnandi? What I have decided is this--this review will cover only the old model Mnandi.  I haven't extensively used the new model, though I have played with it, and while I THINK I can guess at a score, I am not sure.  Its not fair for me to guess though, and so this review will apply only to the old model.

What's the difference, you might be wondering?  Well, the Mnandi has a thumb cut in the blade, kind of like a very wide nail knick.  On the old model, the top most edge was perfect for grabbing the meat of your thumb and allowing the knife to open with one hand.  That edge was just sharp enough for you to get some traction and pop open the knife.  On the new model that edge has been rounded over and while it is possible to open the knife one handed still it is a MUCH more difficult task.  If the Mnandi has started out as a two-hand opening knife I am not sure anyone would complain--after all I love the Indian River Jack and it is a two hand opening knife--but when the original was a one hand opener AND the Mnandi (and all of Chris Reeve's knives) is done in the modern style, the loss of a great and interesting one handed deployment method is a big deal.  I know I am not the only one that dislikes the  change.  Virtually every Mnandi posted on BST boards specifies that it is the "old style" nail knick, if it happens to be one of those models.  Its a selling point because its something people like.  

Of course the problem is that you can't go to a store and buy an old model (though retailers would start advertising used ones or new old stock if they were paying attention).  So this review is not exactly the kind of review I like to put out--it is a review of something that is not readily available.  That said you can find Mnandi's of the old style on forums, so look closely.  Perhaps if there is enough push back, Chris Reeve Knives will offer both versions or revert back to the old style nail knick.  As it was, the old model Mnandi just happens to be one of the best knives available.  Read on to find out why.

Here is the product page. The CRK Mnandi comes in a wide variety of handle materials and there are also damascus steel versions.  The base version costs $375. Here is a written review from the knife's owner. Here is a video review. Here is a link to Blade HQ, where you can find the Mnandi, and all proceeds benefit the site when you purchase things through this link:

Blade HQ

Here is my review sample (borrowed and returned to BladeReview's Dan): 

P1040372

My video overview:


Twitter Review Summary: A combination of looks and performance that is stunning at the price point.

Design: 2

P1040374

In many ways the Mnandi is the knife the Sebenza should be.  It is a more elegant and refined design.  Chris Reeve has talked about how he had conceived the Sebenza as a knife designed for inlays, but the Mnandi is the knife that carries that promise to its logical endpoint.  The Mnandi is to the Sebenza what the Wave is to the PST--a new generation of tool with all of the improvements in design and implementation that were not available when the first generation was made.  Instead of a stamped pocket clip (which is a very good design, BTW) you get an elegant 3D sculpted clip. Instead of strips of inlay/onlay material you get a handle that is almost entirely an inlay, but done in a way that is both beautiful and still quite useable. Then there is the opening method--instead of a boring thumb stud, you get an elegant and effective mega-sized nail knick.  The opening method is especially nice because, unlike the thumb stud, it is not a wart you have to ignore when evaluating the aesthetics of the knife, but something that is part of and complements the looks of the knife in general.  The Mnandi is, in many ways, the Sebenza evolved.  And the fact that Chris Reeve could iterate on one of the best knife designs in the world and both make it better and make it different, is a sign of just how incredible of a designer he is.  

As a blue print, the Mnandi is a knife of singular beauty--a blade that matches or bests the aesthetics of custom knives ten times its price.  The Mnandi, like the Sebenza, is such a good value because it has the good attributes of a custom--superlative fit and finish, a beautiful and unique look--with the good attributes of a production--availability and sane(ish) prices.  Its odd to say that a knife that STARTS at $375 is a good value, but there is just no way to avoid that conclusion, given what you get for the money compared to other knives like it on the market.  

Sizewise, the Mnandi has delicious ratios thanks to its featherweight.  The blade:handle is .76, respectable, but not insane.

P1040379

The blade:weight is 1.83, which is VERY good. 

Fit and Finish: 2

I could simply say this is a CRK knife and move on, but that's not enough.  All of the normal nitpicky things knife knuts care about are dead on perfect.  Here is a rare shot of blade centering where I was able to get the camera almost perfectly head on:

P1040387

If it appears even slighlty off, know it is my fault, not the knife's.  Everything is like this, of course, but the inlay deserves special mention.  Inlays are tricky business--too gaudy and the knife is done and they are a bitch to put on.  Here, leveraging CRK's machining prowess and 3M UHB industrial tape, CRK manages to make a classy inlay that is seamlessly integrated and beautifully implemented.  This is, simply put, the best inlay I have seen on anything short of a megabucks art knife.  Sure the Howard Hitchmough's of the world do this better, but those knives start well north of $5,000.  For us mere mortals, this is as good as it gets.  Additionally, unlike many knives, the insane level of fit and finish isn't just a machinist's masturbation, it serves the overall function of the knife--the inlays are great and they work.

Grip: 2

Its very surprising to find out you can get a full four finger grip on the Mnandi. A knife of this size is usually a three finger plus grip, but here you get all four fingers.  I am not exactly sure why that is, or more to the point why other knives of this size can't do the same thing.

P1040376

The grip is also quite secure thanks to some real jimping on top and a nice curve for your two front fingers.  The inlay and clip are also nice, staying out of the way, and not causing hotspots.

Carry: 2

You know by now that I like options and the Mnandi gives you two.  Dan prefers the slip case carry and I don't blame him.  A knife this elegant deserves something a little better than banging around your pocket with some keys and a few dirty coins.

P1040370

But if you are a true minimalist you also get a very nice pocket clip that both works well and looks nice.  Another area where the Mnandi is just awesome.

Steel: 2 

The old style Mnandi came with S30V, while the new version comes with S35VN.  We are right at the point where technology is pushing hard to make S30V a 1 instead of a 2 steel.  I have found that it is chippy and hard to sharpen.  But the Mnandi's S30V is a little different than the average because CRK heat treats it to a lower HRc, addressing both problems I have with the steel.  Honestly I am not sure how much longer "regular" S30V will get a 2, but here, you have something different than "regular" and it is better for it.

Blade Shape: 2

As with almost everything about this knife, the slender clip point is not just wonderfully effective it is also absolutely stunning.  This is a great cutter and a great looker.  Its pointy enough with out being unnecessarily frail or thin.  I could go on, but it would be pointless--this is a great blade shape, it fits the knife well, and looks amazing.

Grind: 2 

You can go watch the Blade HQ video on Chris's new grind for the 25 and it might get you thinking.  But really there is nothing wrong at all with the CRK high hollow grind you will find here and on the Sebenza.  This is simply one of the best grinds out there.  I loved cutting stuff with the Mnandi.  It was razor sharp, quick through material and steady on the line thanks to a superb grind.  If you watch Jacques Pepin's cooking videos (which, as a knife fan you should, dude has more knife skills than just about anyone on Planet Earth), you'll see the master chef slice and cut meat effortlessly (or debone a chicken in about 56 seconds).  The Mnandi worked the same.  Dan sent it razor sharp and the grind just made it all the better at cutting.  I actually prefer the Mnandi to the Sebenza when it came to cutting.  You just don't need all that thickness in an EDC knife.

Deployment Method: 2 

Ah and here we arrive at the big difference between the two Mnandi models.  The wide nail knick with the sharp upper edge is awesome.  It is one of the very few deployment methods that does not subtract from the visuals of the knife but remains easy to open.

P1040386

Flippers, holes, disks, and studs all, at best doesn't clash with a knife's style, but here we have something that actually accentuates it.  The minimalist look doesn't sacrifice ease of use, either.  The old style knick is a reliable and easy one hand opening knife.  Its just that good.  The new knick, is, however, something a botch job, like Tara Reid's...um...hair.  The new knick, just doesn't work.  Its too rounded over to get a purchase on and as a result it lessens the functionality of the knife.  I can't say that I am fan of this change.  Perhaps CRK can produce both--one for the US and other jurisdictions that allow for one handed opening knives and the other for more restrictive jurisdictions.

Retention Method: 2

The Sebenza clip is great. It really is.  But it is not a looker by any means.  The Mnandi's clip, like the rest of the knife is both great looking and highly functional. 

P1040384

Its remarkable to find a fully 3D machined pocket clip on a knife this price.  Many customs don't offer such a feature and those that do are rarely this well executed.  The fact that the attachment point is both a stand off and a fastner is really a clean, clever touch.  

Lock: 2

I am not an adherent to the early lock up mentality.  To me, basic physics seems to favor a large surface area of contact to ensure firm lock up.  The Fellhoelter Dauntless has a lot of contact.  There is some worry, I suppose, about wearing out the lock, but if it is properly made that won't be a realistic concern, especially in an EDC knife.  Here, as you can see:

P1040388

lock up is late.  The entire lock face meets the rear of the blade.  The lock was easy to engage and disengage and there was no play in any direction.  Excellent lock.  

Overall Score: 20 out of 20  



In my mind the Sebenza is a piece of furniture from a Bauhaus designer--spare, reduced to its essential components, and without flourish of any kind.  In that same mode, the Mnandi reminds me of Greene and Greene furniture--elegant, purposeful, with sneakily difficult to pull off flourishes.  As a woodworker, the Greene and Greene style is definitely my favorite.  It looks quite simple, but execution of even their simplest piece is maddeningly difficult.  So too here with the Mnandi.  The inlay is so large, so perfectly integrated into the knife, that only upon consideration do you realize how difficult it was to do. CRK's trick is the use of an industrial bonding tape, 3M "tape" used to adhere window curtains to skyscraper frames.  Its also made possible but CRK's insanely great machining.  A couple of sources, videos and posts from folks in the industry, reveal the source of CRK's machining greatness--he insists on standards and tolerances that exceed even those in the aerospace industry.  Then there is the third front of greatness: the look.  The Mnandi's shape and curve is subtle, but like nothing else on the market.  In silhouette, it appears graceful and agile.  This is a knife that has visual tension in spades.  

And so we arrive at a perfect knife through three amazing feats--superlative and tasteful adornments, a leveraging of production methods that are higher than those anywhere else in the industry, and a shape that, while not looking avante garde, is unlike anything else.  Anyone of these attributes would make the Mnandi great, all three make it worthy of that stylized CR logo on the pivot.  This is probably one of the two or three finest production blades available for EDC.  It is also good enough that I am going to rescore the Sebenza.  Having had this knife, I realize just how much better it is than the Sebenza.  The Sebenza is great, don't get me wrong, but this knife does everything the Sebenza does as well and it does other things too.  

Some folks will prefer the Sebenza because the Mnandi is "too small."  I like small knives so that doesn't bother me.  What bothers me is that they screwed up the new models with a dumb nail knick. 

The Competition

I have handled a few knives that are good rivals for the Mnandi--the William Henry EDC-6, the Strider PT CC, the Spyderco Caly3, and the Indian River Jack.  I have a strong dislike for the EDC-6, thanks to its reptilian like handle scales and dinky feel.  The Strider is a great knife, but not as refined and is not as good a slicer (thanks to its thick full flat grind).  The Caly3 is quite good, but lacks some of the inventive touches that the Mnandi does--its not quite the looker and is a little bigger than what I find ideal.  This leaves the Indian River Jack.  For me, it is a tough call.  Both are amazing blades.  If you favor more modern styling the Mnandi is the way to go.  If you don't and like the traditional look, obviously the Indian River Jack is your choice.  If you have no preference, opt for the Indian River Jack, its $250 less.  Both are great knives and both make excellent higher end EDCs, but one is very expensive and the other is merely pricey.  This is like picking between a Ferrari and a Lamborghini, so there is no bad choice.  I also like the pocket slip on the IRJ better, but that is such a small point.   

Wednesday, December 10, 2014

HL Human Sponsor

Brad Dowdy, friend of the site and Pen Addict extraordinaire, has, as many of you know, launched a business that makes really damn good pen cases and other stationary stuff called Nock Co.  I loved my Nock Co. Lookout.  He and his business partner Jeff have branched out into EDC gear at their new site HL Human.  They reached out to me and we set up a link to the right.  They are helping out the blog.  Go take a look at what they have.  Right now they have a good selection of 47s lights and a really interesting and exclusive design for a key hook called the Pelican.

I never mind sending people to businesses that do stuff the right way and Nock Co and HL Human do just that.   

Monday, December 8, 2014

Trolling for Hate: Why I am Struggling with Watch Reviews

Since I launched the site I have wanted to do watch reviews.  I have tried a few times and each time has ended in failure.  Watches are much more complicated than knives and flashlights.  Their  long history and technical sophistication make it difficult to penetrate watch jargon and speak with confidence when evaluating watches.  But there are a few other issues that watches present that make it hard for me to review them.  In essence, the problem is this--watches are fashion items.  As handy as they are, watches aren't tools and I review tools.  I like pretty tools as much as the next dude, but watches aren't tools first and foremost (or at least the watches people find interesting aren't).  Here is how you know they aren't tools--the more expensive watches do not perform their designated function better than less expensive watches.  That is, a quartz watch keeps better time than a Rolex.  And when price is wholly detached from performance, you are not looking at tool you are looking at something else.

Complications

Watches do a lot of different things--tell time, tell the day and date, act as a stopwatch--there are myriad functions of some watches (called complications).  And the guts of a watch are literal engineering masterpieces.  Coiled springs and escapements and the like all make watch evaluation complex.  Its like reviewing a computer or a AVR--the more functions and the more complex something is the hard it is to fully evaluate.  Watches are the EDC equivalent of the massive $4,000 Denon receiver--there is just a lot going on in that little case.  All of these extras bring up an issue fundamental to consumerism--feature creep.  How many of these doodads matter?  Do you REALLY need to know the phase of the moon?  They are complicated and, in many was, unnecessarily so.  

Jewelry

Let's face facts--alot of what we carry we carry because it looks nice.  It is, as Andrew put it, pocket frosting.  The knife, the light, the OPMT, they all have functions, but if it were strictly about performance we'd all have Dragonfly IIs in ZDP-189.  Its not and we like ornamentation (I don't really, but even I have a Damascus bladed knife).  But unless you have a collection of William Henry knives, a knife is, first and foremost, a tool.  Its looks are secondary.  And we know this because increased cost is linked to increased performance.  Of course, at the top end, marginal performance improvements come at a very high cost, but that is the way all goods function.  But comparing the top and the bottom of the market is illustrative--a San Ren Mu 605 does not out perform a Spyderco Dragonfly II or a Jon Graham Midtech Stubby Razel.  But with watches, the same is not true at all.  A $12 quartz keeps better time than a $12,000 Rolex.  And because that is true, watches are not tools, first and foremost.  Your money is paying for things other than performance.  Its paying for looks, for jewels on the watch face (another hint that watches are jewelry), and it is paying for some mythical quality called "exclusivity".  You know what things that cost more solely because of exclusivity are called?  Veblen Goods.  High end watches, to a large degree, are Veblen goods.  The sole purpose of a high price tag is to make the good seem exclusive.  

There are a few good ways to ferret out BS in the watch market.  Many movements are made by ETA.  Search for a given movement and then look at the prices of the watches with that movement.  Next, look to see if the watches have exotic materials that could otherwise justifiy the cost difference. If not, then the cost difference is based on some mystical "brand exclusivity."  In many ways this strikes me as stupid as things like "premium vodka."  The legal definition of vodka is that it is a tasteless and odorless spirit.  How can their be PREMIUM vodkas when they are required to be the same and not just the same thing, but similarly devoid of distinguishing characteristics?

I was looking at a Sinn watch and a Hamilton.  They had similar materials--steel, sapphire crystal, leather band--and they had an identical ETA movement.  But they were $1000 apart, with the Sinn being more expensive.  This particular Sinn did not have the "tegimented" steel or the inert gas interior. It was the 556. 


The Hamilton was the HML-H70455533. 



What's the difference between the two watches other than looks and "brand exclusivity"?  Nothing.  They have the exact same movements. 

And that is one reason why watches are hard to evaluate. The differences are stylistic and brand based and not, well, reality based.  I appreciate good looking tools, but evaluating them solely on that basis is something I am neither good at nor interested in.  Frankly, many premium watches are jewelry and that is fine, but I am not interested in jewelry.  Skull rings or dinner plate sized five figure watches just don't interest me.  

Out of Step

The last reason I am struggling with watch reviews has to do with my tastes.  While this is a gear blog and gear are tools, I am a person that appreciates style.  The problem is, the style I like in watches--quiet, muted, and durable, is not the style that is in right now.  We went from 38mm up to 46mm and larger faces.  The problem is only Randy Jackson can get away with wearing 50mm watches.  The rest of us look silly.  But increasingly that is all there is.

I am also not a huge fan of the dive watch look.  If it was about function, that would be one thing, but the dive watch look is worn by divers about .01% of the time and posers the rest of the time.  The Humvee look is just something that blinds my mind's eye and offends my sense of style (what little I have).  I like the aesthetic some of the time, but is WAY over done, especially when combined with the other trend I don't like--big watches.  I don't want to wear a dinner plate on my wrist, even if it does have dominos on it so I can tell time.



Finally, there is the distinct lack of minimalism.  I get that complications show of a watch maker's prowess, but I buy gear to use not to show off (and yes, I begrudingly do Instagram...frankly I hate it, but so many gear folks are there, I figure I have to participate).  And so faces like this one:

just about kill me.  A quick glance at the face of the watch and you can find about 15 mortal design sins, things that would never fly in my favorite design book--Design of Everyday Things.  But here is the issue--watch design is not about telling time, it is about jewelry, and there, in the end, is the rub.

Conclusion

I wear one piece of jewelry--my wedding band.  I got married to my wife on my grandparent's 50th wedding anniversary.  As their gift they gave us their bands when they upgraded theirs.  The sentimental value is huge and so I make one exception and wear exactly one item of jewelry.  No Rolex, Patek Phillippe, or Breitling will ever be as meaningful and so I am not going to break the rule for them.

In the end I am going to review watches, and maybe I will work my way up to the Rolexes of the world, but I just don't have the heart to do it right now.  I hate paying for a brand.  I hate paying for exclusivity.  These two burnings hatreds were the fuel that made me start this blog.  And now that I have come to watches I am saddened to realize that most of what makes them what they are are things I disdain.  The watch industry is bent on selling an image, and I get that most things are doing that, but in the watch business it seems like it is 99% image and 1% thing on your wrist.  Unlike what the ads tell you watches don't make you interesting.  Being interesting does that.  Watches won't make you wealthy, having wealth does that (and in fact, given the meteoric rise in prices of Swiss made watches they seem to do the opposite).  And watches certainly won't make you a person of distinction, doing the right thing will do that.  So take the celebrity photos, Bond movie product placements, bathyscape stuns, and other watch marketing bullshit and shove it.

I will probably end up reviewing a few $100-$1000 watches, but beyond that, I am not sure what I am paying for, and when that happens, you have left the realm of rational purchases and entered a bizarro world where spending money results in poorer performance.  Watches, after a certain point, are all style and no substance.  My opinion is always subject to change (one smart man told me that a wise person is always one good argument away from changing their mind), but for now I can't wrap my head around pure luxury watches.

Tell me I am wrong.  I really want to learn and thus far, after three years of on and off research, I have failed.   

Thursday, December 4, 2014

Triple Aught Design Fellhoelter Compact Dauntless Review

EDITOR'S NOTE: I am not ashamed to admit it--I am as biased as the next person.  I have preferences.  But as a reviewer I want to do what I can to limit their influence on the score of a product.  Most of the time that involves me stating what they are and noting where opinions may diverge.  In some instances, the biases are so strong I don't feel like I can do a good job reviewing a product.  This was one of those instances.  Ben stepped up and filed in quite nicely.  I'd give it the same score, 20 out of 20.  I am not sure if I am willing to give it a perfect score, maybe over time I will.

Despite setting trends that are followed in the production knife world (titanium, framelock, flipper, zzz...), the custom knife scene operates largely on a maker-by-maker, owner-by-owner basis: the purchase and ownership of a custom knife is often about, or at least often becomes about, what rings the buyer’s cherry, and questions of utility and design fall by the wayside in the rarified air of grail knives and acquisition. This is a shame, at least from a gear reviewer’s perspective, because while most customs are doomed to lives as safe queens, and indeed often seemed designed with this end in mind, just as often they are extremely well-designed, and of such a degree of quality that not using them is almost an insult to the knife. I’m happy to say that the Compact Fellhoelter Custom Dauntless (forthwith for brevity’s sake the Compact Dauntless) falls into that second camp. It is beautiful, yes, and certainly collectible, but it is first and foremost a wonderful knife--that is to say a wonderful tool.

Here is the product page on TAD’s website. This knife, which is, of course, not readily available, costs $630. I couldn’t find any written reviews. Here is Tony’s overview, which is the only video commentary I found.

Here is the review sample, Tony’s personal Compact Dauntless:

P1030871

Twitter Review Summary: Unassailably good design, a wonderful aesthetic, and definite utility make this knife a pleasure to use.

Design: 2

The Compact Dauntless is a product of the Dauntless Project, a sort of design initiative from Triple Aught Design, who led the charge with their own Dauntless knife, and then had custom makers all put their spin on the central concept. This was/is a brilliant idea, and going to TAD’s website and looking at the Dauntless page is, I should warn you, a foray into extremely explicit knife porn (the Jarosz Knives Mod 75, hummuna hummunna).

P1030873

The conceit for Brian Fellhoelter’s Dauntless is right in the name: it’s compact. Most of the other Dauntless knives, including the flagship production model, are quite large, usually in the neighborhood of 3.5”. Larger knives have their place, and can even be reasonably EDC’d, but to have those Dauntless bones scaled down into something, well, compact and easily pocketable is a wonderful thing. That is the core of the Compact Dauntless’s greatness, but there are many small touches that contribute as well: the way the length of the clip keeps the knife in place in your pocket, the control afforded by the two finger choils, the texturing on the inside of the framelock for disengagement, the raised, jimped area for greater comfort when you’re cutting at an angle...it’s all good. There’s nothing avant-garde about the knife; the Compact Dauntless’s design greatness doesn’t come from wild innovation, but rather from a relentless attention to what works for a knife of its size, and the near-flawless execution thereof.

The blade:handle is .77, nothing inspirational, but this the glory of the Compact Dauntless isn’t in the broad strokes stuff; the details make it great. Also, you’ll notice that the custom TAD hardware looks badass yet still needs just a standard torx driver to disassemble. Hmm, wow, it’s almost like there’s NO REASON to use proprietary screws on a knife, period...

Fit and Finish: 2

No surprises here. We know that production knife companies are capable of absolutely stunning fit and finish, but what I think you get when you step up into a custom is what could almost be called “warmness”: everything that can, and should be smooth, is: all the edges are chamfered, and the seam between the G10 scale and the titanium lockbar side is so tightly done that it passes the fingernail test. I mentioned it above, but there is texturing on the inside of the disengagement area of the lockbar, and it is done so perfectly: it catches your finger without being abrading at all. The fact that the designer’s name and the year of manufacture are machined into the inside of the G10 scale is just too cool. Stunning.

P1030875

Grip: 2

This knife is a thick little chunk of G10 and titanium, and that, along with the forward choil and smoothed-over overall polish, makes it pretty great in the hand. That being said, there is a small issue with that forward choil: my finger has a tendency to push forward a little bit, right on to the cutting edge, when I’m making a cut of any force. I’m not sure this would be an issue for all users, but if you compare it to the choil on the Strider PT CC, which has a more defined ricasso, or the one on the Caly 3 CF, which is a lot wider and more accommodating, you’ll see that it is lacking.

P1030879

It may just be the way I hold the knife, and at any rate a modicum of knife sense will alleviate the issue entirely, and so while it’s worth noting, it’s not worth docking this knife a point. And, as also mentioned above, the raised jimping on top not only facilitates traction, but indexes your thumb perfectly for downward cuts.

Carry: 2

This knife is thick, but not obtrusively so, and the long clip keeps it from knocking around at all in your pocket.

P1030874

It doesn’t disappear, but it doesn’t intrude. Along with my Three Sisters Forge Beast, this knife convinced me of the benefits of a long clip. Very good.

Steel: 2

154CM has always been an underrated steel. In my experience it outperforms VG10 in edge retention (what doesn’t?), sharpens about as easily as AUS-8, and is more durable than S30V. I class it alongside N690, although I’ve never been able to get my 154CM blades as sharp as my N690 ones. This blade uses CPM 154, the powder metallurgy variant of 154CM, which enhances the qualities I like in the standard iteration. I didn’t sharpen this knife, because as this isn’t my blade I didn’t want to wear it down to the point where it would need sharpening, but I do own an Northwoods Knives Indian River Jack and had absolutely no problems getting that thing nice and sharp.

Also I really like the finish on the Compact Dauntless. It looks almost as if it were beadblasted and then stonewashed; whatever was done, the end result is a muted but very attractive finish that I’d imagine, were this knife to be used hard (Tony you should try some batonning!), would wear very well.

Blade Shape: 2

An almost squaloid drop point blade that is proportionally narrower than that of the production Dauntless, with a gracile curve from the main edge up to the point, this blade tells me that Brian Fellhoelter intended for this knife to see actual use: it performs just about any reasonable cutting task with ease.  I always find that if I don’t have a lot to say about the shape of the blade, that’s usually because it’s great, and that is certainly the case here.

Grind: 2

The lines of this grind are beautiful. Although I tend to be ambivalent about swedges, the one on the Compact Dauntless is, in keeping with the rest of the knife, perfectly done, and I find that it contributes to the sleek machinist aesthetic of the knife, instead of coming across as “tactical.” The knife is ground from fairly thick stock, and often thicker knives sacrifice too much cutting ability in favor of extra durability. However, the balance is just right here, with the flat grind on the Compact Dauntless, which starts about a third of the way down the blade, steep enough, and the cutting bevel wide and even enough, to ensure good, although not stellar, all-around performance. The beauty of the blade, and the general competence in cutting tasks, as well as the bump in durability over other smallish slicers like the Dragonfly, are enough to warrant two points.

Deployment Method: 2

Tony, in the update to his overview, illustrates the way he found best to open the Compact Dauntless. You may have to think about deploying this knife a little more than you would something with an opening hole, but the tradeoff is a reliable and fast deployment, every single time. That is a point that bears emphasis: the detent is perfectly balanced, and this knife FLIES out of the handle. Even trying, I couldn’t get this knife to open only halfway, or not lock up properly.

Lock: 2

Framelocks are probably my least favorite knife locks. They have their benefits, I know, but I’ve always found that they are more finicky and require more care than a liner lock or a lockback (which, the longer I use and handle knives, the more I appreciate). Even something more mechanically complex, like an Axis Lock, has been more reliable in my experience. That being said, the Compact Dauntless has the best framelock I’ve ever used. Its lockup is as sure and confident as its deployment.

P1030876

I can’t tell if the lockface is carbidized or not, and I didn’t get to handle the knife when it was brand new and not broken in, but there is no stickiness at all, and disengagement is effortless, in part due to that great texturing on the lockbar. It’s not going to convince me that framelocks are the way to go, but damn if this isn’t a perfect implementation.

Overall Score: 20 out of 20

When looking at custom knives, there’s this question of whether it’s fair compare them to production knives. This line of thought is to the detriment of the discussion of custom knives: they’re treated as something other than just knives, when in fact, that is often exactly what they are: the ultimate expression of a knife, something in which form and function can meet, unhindered by concerns for budget or manufacturing costs or mass appeal or any of the bullshit that plagues a knife company at the drawing board. Sure, there are display customs, and all custom knives are collectible, but so many makers are out there, putting out knives that are amazing tools in addition to being one of a kind.

The Compact Dauntless is such a knife. I cannot say enough good things about it. The aesthetic is super badass, and the size and fit and finish are unbeatable, but it’s the usefulness that leaves an impression. It’s kind of knife you really appreciate if you’ve already handled and used a bunch of different knives. Almost every detail is thought out and well-realized. This is a knife knut’s knife. The biggest issue here is availability. TAD and Brian, you guys want to get started on a production version?

P1030872